Everything Seemed Perfect After the Move Until a Note Inside My Neighbor’s ‘Welcome Pie’ Turned My Blood Cold — Story of the Day

73

I moved to a peaceful suburb to start over, but when I cut into my neighbor’s welcome pie and found a hidden note inside, I knew the past I’d been running from had finally caught up with me.

When the movers finally drove off and the street fell silent, I stood at the top of the driveway, breathing in the stillness. Fifty-eight. Divorced.

Starting over. Again.

This time, I promised myself not to repeat old mistakes. A new chapter had officially begun.

I glanced at the narrow parking strip between my house and the one next door.

The realtor had said it was mine. So I maneuvered my car forward, straightened the wheels, and parked right there.

“Hello there!” a cheerful voice called out.

I turned. A woman in lemon-yellow flats was leaning casually against the fence, holding a watering can.

She looked like someone who never left the house without lip gloss.

“New neighbor?” she asked, smiling.

“Guilty,” I said. “Alicia.”

“Jocelyn,” she replied, setting the watering can down and walking closer. “Welcome to the neighborhood.

You’ll love it here.”

“I hope so. I need a fresh start.”

“Well, you’ve picked the perfect place. We have block brunches on Saturdays, and everyone helps everyone.

It’s very… harmonious.”

I smiled politely, unsure how harmonious I wanted my life to be. Jocelyn’s gaze drifted past me, straight to my car.

“Yes. It’s convenient.

Close to the door.”

“Of course. It’s just… well, I usually park there. Been doing it for years.”

“I was told it came with my property.”

“I’ve always parked there — it’s just easier with groceries and all.”

“But you already have a driveway,” I said calmly.

“I do.

But the sun hits this one differently. Keeps the leather from cracking.”

“Then maybe it’s time to invest in better leather.”

There was a tiny pause, and then Jocelyn laughed. “You’re funny.

I like that. Of course, it’s your spot. Anyway, I’ll drop by tomorrow with a little housewarming gift.

It’s a thing we do here.”

Jocelyn gave a small wave and turned toward her garden. I watched her walk away, the smile never leaving her face until she was out of sight. My own faded as soon as she was gone.

I glanced at my car, perfectly parked where it was supposed to be, and felt an old, familiar instinct stir.

The story doesn’t end here — it continues on the next page.
Tap READ MORE to discover the rest 🔎👇